Inspector General Flags OSHA Data Gaps and Mine Emergency Readiness
The report points to missing employer injury data, nearly 500 OSHA inspections that may have been barred and MSHA recommendations still open from 2017.
- By Danielle Naidu
- Nov 19, 2026
OSHA and MSHA still face significant challenges protecting workers, especially in high-risk industries, according to the Department of Labor's Office of Inspector General (OIG). Its report on the department's top management and performance challenges, released in November, cites unreliable OSHA data, limited inspection resources and unfinished work on mine emergency preparedness.
The OIG pointed to its September 2023 audit, which found that between 2016 and 2020, an average of 59% of establishments across all industries did not submit their required yearly injury and illness reports to OSHA. OSHA also could not tell whether a given establishment had to report. That left the agency unable to remind particular employers to file or to effectively cite those that didn't, the report said.
In September, the OIG alerted OSHA that, based on the OIG's analysis of agency data, OSHA may have conducted nearly 500 inspections of small employers in industries considered low risk over 14 months. An annual appropriations rider may bar those inspections. OSHA's preliminary look at 27 of the case files found four inspections that met none of the exceptions its appropriations acts allow. Officials attributed the other 23 to coding errors.
The OIG said it is concerned OSHA lacks adequate controls, in its systems and in supervision, to make sure inspection data is coded accurately. Errors in that data could undermine the agency's decisions and its enforcement programs, the report said.
OSHA and its state partners have about 1,684 inspectors for more than 11.8 million worksites, or roughly one inspector per 7,000 worksites, according to the report.
For MSHA, the OIG reported in April that the agency needed to better prepare for mine emergencies. Issues included keeping guidance current, issuing withdrawal orders appropriately, having rescue equipment available during emergencies, adequately training emergency staff and reviewing responses afterward. MSHA has since added system controls meant to ensure withdrawal orders are issued properly and set up periodic reviews of its guidance.
Five of nine recommendations from a March 2017 OIG report on mine operators' emergency response plans remain unimplemented. In October 2023, the OIG reported that MSHA went at least two years in a row without inspecting 176 mines. A March 2021 OIG report found MSHA inspectors did not verify that operators fixed hazards by the agency's due date about one-third of the time.
OSHA still needs to finish its efforts to improve employers' severe injury and illness reporting and make its inspection data more accurate, the OIG said. The office also plans to audit OSHA's workplace violence enforcement.
About the Author
Danielle Naidu is assistant editor for Occupational Health & Safety and Environmental Protection Online.