What U.S. Safety Managers Can Learn From Europe’s Written Risk Assessment Rule
Federal OSHA has no general requirement for a comprehensive written risk assessment, but the European approach offers a practical model for documenting hazards, controls and follow-up.
- By Thony Maufay
- Nov 18, 2026
Picture this: one of your employees is seriously injured by a cutting machine. An OSHA inspector visits your facility and asks how you had identified this hazard, what controls were in place, and what you had planned to improve them.
Some employers can answer with a dated record. Many others can only describe from memory what they did. In the U.S., no general federal rule requires a single, comprehensive written risk assessment. In Europe, it is a legal obligation for almost every employer.
I am a safety engineer in France, registered with the French government as an occupational risk prevention specialist (IPRP). My work consists mainly of assessing occupational risks in companies of all kinds: restaurants, hair salons, masonry, plumbing and more. This led me to look at how other countries regulate the subject. The goal is the same everywhere, which is no harm to workers, but the route differs: European law prescribes the process, while U.S. law focuses mainly on the result, supplemented by targeted written requirements. The European model is not a legal requirement in the U.S., but it offers a practical framework that U.S. safety managers can borrow.
What U.S. Rules Require in Writing
Federal law rests on the General Duty Clause, section 5(a)(1) of the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970. It requires every employer to provide a workplace free from recognized hazards that are causing or likely to cause death or serious physical harm.
There is no general federal requirement for a comprehensive written risk assessment covering every hazard in the workplace. However, many OSHA standards require written assessments, programs or records for specific hazards. Examples include the written certification of the PPE hazard assessment (29 CFR 1910.132(d)(2)), the written hazard communication program (29 CFR 1910.1200(e)), documented energy control procedures (29 CFR 1910.147(c)(4)), the written respiratory protection program (29 CFR 1910.134(c)) and injury and illness records (29 CFR Part 1904).
Some states go further. California requires every employer to maintain a written Injury and Illness Prevention Program (Title 8, California Code of Regulations, section 3203), and Washington requires a written Accident Prevention Program (WAC 296-800-140). OSHA's Recommended Practices for Safety and Health Programs also encourage a systematic approach to finding and fixing hazards, on a voluntary basis.
U.S. employers therefore already produce many safety documents. What is often missing is the single document that connects them: one place where every hazard is identified, ranked and linked to its controls.
Europe: One Written Assessment for All Hazards
In France (article R4121-1 of the Labor Code) and more broadly in the European Union (Framework Directive 89/391/EEC), every employer with at least one employee must keep a document that identifies and assesses all the occupational risks workers are exposed to, and lists the prevention measures for each risk. Depending on the country and the size of the company, the requirements can be more or less demanding.
In France, for example, companies with 50 or more employees must also set out, for each measure, a schedule, the people in charge and an estimated cost.
What French Case Law Shows About Documentation
For more than a decade, French courts applied what was known as an "obligation of safety of result": whenever an employee was injured at work, the employer was held liable, whatever it had done to prevent harm.
A 2015 case changed that (Cour de cassation, Social Chamber, Nov. 25, 2015, No. 14-24.444). An Air France cabin crew chief who had watched the Twin Towers collapse from his New York hotel room on Sept. 11, 2001, blamed his employer for the psychological disorders he later developed. The court ruled that the employer was not liable: Air France had taken measures as soon as he returned and had provided medical follow-up, and the judges could not see what more the company could have done.
Since then, French courts examine the risk assessment and, above all, the prevention measures the employer chose and actually implemented. When those measures are found sufficient, the employer may avoid liability.
French case law does not create a legal defense for U.S. employers. But it illustrates a principle that applies anywhere: documentation shows what an employer knew, what it decided and what it did. A dated, regularly updated assessment is concrete evidence of preventive efforts, whether for an inspector, an insurer or your own management team.
Practical Steps for U.S. Safety Managers
Here is how to apply the main features of the European approach in your own workplace:
- Define work units. Before assessing any risk, group together the workers who are exposed to the same hazards. In an auto repair shop, for example, mechanics, tow truck drivers, office staff and body technicians would each form a separate unit.
- Identify hazards with workers. The people who do the job know its hazards best. Walk through each task with them, review injury records and near misses, and rely on recognized sources such as OSHA and the INRS (French National Research and Safety Institute).
- Score the risks consistently. Use one scoring method across the company, for example severity and likelihood, so that hazards can be compared. A consistent method does not replace professional judgment, but it makes that judgment visible and easier to review. Address the highest-scoring hazards first.
- Choose controls using the hierarchy of controls. For each hazard, consider elimination and substitution first, then engineering controls, then administrative controls, and personal protective equipment last.
- Assign responsibility and deadlines. Each corrective action needs an owner, a due date and, where useful, an estimated cost. French law requires this from companies with 50 or more employees, and it is good practice at any size.
- Follow up and verify. Check that each action was completed and that the control actually works, through inspections, measurements or feedback from workers. Record the result.
- Update the assessment and keep every version. Revise it after any significant change, incident or near miss, and keep previous versions. Together, they show how hazards and controls have evolved.
An Example: From Assessment to Improved Controls
Consider an illustrative case based on situations I regularly encounter. In the first version of a small auto repair shop's assessment, exposure to exhaust fumes in the workshop scores high: engines run indoors, and the only control is opening the doors. The assessment assigns the owner to install a vehicle exhaust extraction system within three months. Six months later, the updated version records that the extraction hoses are in place, that mechanics were consulted on their positioning, and that a follow-up check confirmed they are used for every running-engine job. The risk score drops, and the next priority moves up the list. Anyone reading the two versions can see the hazard, the decision, the control and its verification.
Conclusion
Let's go back to the cutting machine. A written assessment would not guarantee that no one is ever injured. But the process of building it is what makes injuries less likely: identifying the hazard with the people exposed to it, choosing a guard or a safer procedure, giving someone responsibility for it and checking that it works.
That is the main lesson U.S. safety managers can take from European rules. A written risk assessment is not paperwork for its own sake. It is a working tool to identify hazards, put controls in place and verify that they protect workers.