Court Reverses $33 Million Verdict, Sides with Hospital in Peer-Review Case

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit last week ruled in favor of Presbyterian Hospital of Dallas by reversing a lower court decision that awarded $33 million in damages in a peer-review case against the hospital (Lawrence R. Poliner, MD v Texas Health Systems, 7/23/08, No. 06-11235).

The case revolved around a suspension of a doctor's cardiac catheterization lab and echocardiography privileges at Presbyterian Hospital, following a peer review of his performance. The doctor sued the hospital and other doctors involved in his peer review, alleging various federal and state law violations. A district court found that the suspension enjoyed immunity from money damages under the federal Health Care Quality Improvement Act (HCQIA) and granted a partial summary judgment, but the court also decided that whether the temporary restrictions of privileges during the investigation had immunity from money damages presented questions for a jury.

The case proceeded to trial solely on the temporary restrictions of privileges. The jury found for the suspended doctor on defamation claims he had raised. The doctor was able to offer evidence at trial of actual loss of income of about $10,000 but was awarded more than $90 million in defamation damages, nearly all for mental anguish and injury to career. The jury also awarded $110 million in punitive damages. The district court ordered a remittitur of the damages and entered judgment against the defending hospital and peer-review team.

On appeal, the Fifth Circuit held that the defendants are immune under HCQIA from money damages for the temporary restrictions of the doctor's privileges. "The congressional grant of immunity accepts that few physicians would be willing to serve on peer review committees under such a threat," the court noted, citing a Third Circuit explanation that "'the intent of [HCQIA] was not to disturb, but to reinforce, the preexisting reluctance of courts to substitute their judgment on the merits for that of health care professionals and of the governing bodies of hospitals in an area within their expertise.'"

The Fifth Circuit concluded: "Not only has [the doctor] failed to rebut the statutory presumption that the peer review actions were taken in compliance with the statutory standards, the evidence independently demonstrates that the peer review actions met the statutory requirements." An amicus brief filed in the case last year by the American Hospital Association and other heath care organizations urged that hospitals "be allowed the full freedom afforded by HCQIA to protect patients and to improve the quality of care," and that the judgment of the lower court be reversed. Last Wednesday, the Fifth Circuit agreed.

 

Download Center

  • Safety Metrics Guide

    Is your company leveraging its safety data and analytics to maintain a safe workplace? With so much data available, where do you start? This downloadable guide will give you insight on helpful key performance indicators (KPIs) you should track for your safety program.

  • Job Hazard Analysis Guide

    This guide includes details on how to conduct a thorough Job Hazard Analysis, and it's based directly on an OSHA publication for conducting JHAs. Learn how to identify potential hazards associated with each task of a job and set controls to mitigate hazard risks.

  • A Guide to Practicing “New Safety”

    Learn from safety professionals from around the world as they share their perspectives on various “new views” of safety, including Safety Differently, Safety-II, No Safety, Human and Organizational Performance (HOP), Resilience Engineering, and more in this helpful guide.

  • Lone Worker Safety Guide

    As organizations digitalize and remote operations become more commonplace, the number of lone workers is on the rise. These employees are at increased risk for unaddressed workplace accidents or emergencies. This guide was created to help employers better understand common lone worker risks and solutions for lone worker risk mitigation and incident prevention.

  • EHS Software Buyer's Guide

    Learn the keys to staying organized, staying sharp, and staying one step ahead on all things safety. This buyer’s guide is designed for you to use in your search for the safety management solution that best suits your company’s needs.

  • Vector Solutions

Featured Whitepaper

OH&S Digital Edition

  • OHS Magazine Digital Edition - May 2022

    May 2022

    Featuring:

    • WEARABLE TECHNOLOGY
      How Wearable Technology is Transforming Safety and the Industrial Workplace
    • TRAINING: CONFINED SPACES
      Five Tips to Improve Safety in Confined Spaces
    • INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
      Monitor for Asbestos to Help Save Lives
    • PPE: FALL PROTECTION
      Fall Protection Can Be Surprising
    View This Issue