Million-Dollar Recordkeeping Case Still Alive

One of the contested cases arising out of OSHA's 1990 egregious penalty policy is still undecided, although the inspection that resulted in a $1,062,000 proposed penalty against Jindal United Steel Corp. for recordkeeping violations at its Baytown, Texas, plant ended Oct. 19, 2000. The Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission on Aug. 16, 2007, sent the case back to Administrative Law Judge James H. Barkley after the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Barkley erred by grouping 82 recordkeeping violations he affirmed as willful and assessing a single penalty of $70,000 for them.

OSHA developed the egregious policy to send a message by penalizing certain employers instance-by-instance. Seven factors were weighed in deciding whether a case qualified as egregious/willful; they included a clear showing of bad faith by the employer and a high number of injuries/illnesses. The Jindal case involves 110 willful violations in all, with the department seeking a $9,000 penalty for each, but OSHRC's chairman in September 2005, W. Scott Railton, concluded the violations were of low gravity and injuries/illnesses that went unreported were relatively minor. OSHRC had just two commissioners at that time who could not agree on the penalty: Commissioner Thomasina Rogers held that the amended OSH Act requires a penalty of at least $5,000 for each willful violation -- amounting to $410,000 in this case, which Railton considered excessive.

Unable to decide the case, the two commissioners vacated the direction for review and allowed Barkley's order to become the final appealable order in the case; the 5th Circuit's decision to vacate his penalty assessment means Barkley must revise his decision.

Download Center

HTML - No Current Item Deck
  • Green Quadrant EHS Software 2021

    Reserve your copy of the new report by independent analyst firm, Verdantix, to get a detailed, fact-based comparison of the 22 most prominent EHS software vendors in the industry.

  • Best Practices to Navigate ISO 45001

    Learn helpful tips and tricks to navigate your transition to ISO 45001 certification and ensure an effective health and safety management system.

  • Improve Your Safety Culture

    Learn the 3 fundamental areas to focus on to achieve safety culture excellence and what you can do to boost employee engagement in your EHS programs.

  • Chemical Safety: 5 Questions Answered by Experts

    Get answers to 5 of the most frequently asked questions about how to effectively mitigate chemical risk, get the most value out of your chemical data, and gain buy-in for a chemical management technology program.

  • How Has COVID-19 Changed Safety Culture?

    The COVID-19 pandemic has provided unique opportunities for health and safety professionals to rethink how they manage risk and develop stronger safety cultures. Read this eBook to learn actionable steps you can implement today to improve your programs.

  • Industry Safe

OH&S Digital Edition

  • OHS Magazine Digital Edition - January February 2021

    January February 2021

    Featuring:

    • TRAINING: SOFTWARE
      Tips for Choosing the Best Training Software
    • COMBUSTIBLE DUST
      Assessing the Dangers of Dust Explosions
    • HAND PROTECTION
      Pushing the Boundaries of Hand Protection
    • FOOT PROTECTION
      Getting a Grip on Slip Resistance
    View This Issue