An Overprotected Fire Service?

WHY am I pondering the cost of U.S. firefighters' injuries? The bottom line of a sincere, recent effort to count these injuries and estimate their cost is no great shock to me: There is no clear bottom line. Applying five possible methods to the 80,800 U.S. civilian firefighter injuries in 2002 produced cost estimates from an impossibly low $300 million all the way up to $16.7 billion. The "Economic Consequences Of Firefighter Injuries and Their Prevention" report threw out the highest and lowest, leaving a final estimate that is between $2.8 billion and $7.8 billion.

What is startling is part of the report's analysis of the 20 percent decline in injuries since 1992. Contributing factors include a drop in fires fought, safety features added to fire vehicles, better PPE, improved safety practices, and federal grants that allowed many departments to acquire improved gear and equipment they once lacked, said the report, which was prepared by TriData Corp. of Arlington, Va. for the Building and Fire Research Laboratory of the National Institute of Standards and Technology.

What else does it say? Firefighters' PPE may be getting too good. "The use of self-contained breathing apparatus (SCBA) is the norm in fire suppression operations, and most firefighters are equipped with Nomex hoods, which cover their ears and neck. A new problem is threatening to develop, however," the report says. "As protective gear has improved, firefighters can get deeper into a fire and remain there for long periods of time before they feel the heat and realize they should retreat. This situation puts the firefighter at risk. Protective ensembles may have become almost too effective."

I haven't heard anyone complain modern police vests are too bulletproof or body armor protects troops in Iraq too well. But seeing TriData acknowledge seven active fire department officers for technical assistance tells me this overprotection concern must exist among high-ranking fire service personnel.

The report's top recommendation is improving public education and prevention to reduce the number of emergency calls. No argument there; prevention is always smarter than cleanup or protection. Other recommendations cover safer training, use of robotics, instilling safety awareness in firefighters, sensors to transmit pulse rates and detect wounds, early detection of building collapses, and much higher adherence to NFPA's 1583 standard on fitness programs for firefighters. But my gut tells me PPE can't be too protective in the face of a $5 billion annual injury cost. If it is, let's look to the wearer's attitude rather than push for lesser products.The report is online at

This column appears in the June 2005 issue of Occupational Health & Safety.

This article originally appeared in the June 2005 issue of Occupational Health & Safety.

About the Author

Jerry Laws is Editor of Occupational Health & Safety magazine, which is owned by 1105 Media Inc.

Download Center

  • The Ultimate Guide to OSHA Recordkeeping

    When it comes to OSHA recordkeeping, there are always questions regarding the requirements and in and outs. This guide is here to help!

  • Lone Worker Safety Guide

    As organizations digitalize and remote operations become more commonplace, the number of lone workers is on the rise. These employees are at increased risk for unaddressed workplace accidents or emergencies. This guide was created to help employers better understand common lone worker risks and solutions for lone worker risk mitigation and incident prevention.

  • Online Safety Training Buyer's Guide

    Thinking of getting an online safety training solution at work but not sure how to evaluate different solutions and find the one that's best for your company? Use this handy buyer's guide to learn the basics of selecting online safety training and how to use it at your workplace.

  • SDS Software Buyer's Guide

    Whether this is your first time shopping for online SDS software or you’re upgrading from a legacy solution, this guide is designed for you to use in your search for the safety management solution that works best for you and your company.

  • Risk Matrix Guide

    Risk matrices come in many different shapes and sizes. Understanding the components of a risk matrix will allow you and your organization to manage risk effectively.

  • Vector Solutions

OH&S Digital Edition

  • OHS Magazine Digital Edition - November December 2021

    November December 2021


      How to Streamline Gas Detector Maintenance
    • OSHA TOP 10
      OSHA's Top 10 Most Frequently Cited Standards for FY 2021
      How PPE Can Help You Deal with the Harsh Condition of Winter
      Tackling Hearing Protection in the Workplace
    View This Issue