DC Circuit's Process Safety Decision a Setback for OSHA

In a unanimous decision, three D.C. Circuit judges -- Sri Srinivasan, Judith W. Rogers, and Patricia A. Millett -- ruled that OSHA failed to follow the required notice-and-comment procedure when it narrowed the retail exemption in its PSM standard following the West Fertilizer explosion in 2013.

OSHA lost an important federal appeals court case on Sept. 23 when a panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit ruled unanimously that the agency had not properly changed the retail facilities exemption in its Process Safety Management (PSM) standard following the explosion at a fertilizer facility in West, Texas, on April 17, 2013. Fifteen people died in the explosion, 12 of whom were firefighters trying to quench the fire at the West Fertilizer Company when 30 tons of stored ammonium nitrate exploded.

In the aftermath of the disaster, the White House directed several executive agencies, including the Labor Department and EPA, to examine their process safety management and hazmat regulations in light of the event and recommend changes in those regulations to prevent another such catastrophe. OSHA's actions included changing the PSM standard, which all along had exempted retail facilities from its requirements. OSHA narrowed the scope of the exemption so the standard would cover formerly exempt facilities like the West plant, and the D.C. Circuit panel -- Judges Sri Srinivasan, Judith W. Rogers, and Patricia A. Millett -- ruled in Agricultural Retailers Association and the Fertilizer Institute v. U.S. Department of Labor and OSHA, No. 15-1326, that OSHA by this action was enacting a standard, but the agency failed to follow the required notice-and-comment procedures for standards established in the OSH Act.

"As OSHA describes the measure, it aims to eliminate 'policy and regulatory gaps' so as to help 'prevent incidents like the West Fertilizer explosion.' OSHA, Questions and Answers—PSM Retail Exemption Policy, July 22, 2015. By redefining retail facilities, the Memorandum, in purpose and effect, subjects a substantial number of businesses previously classified as exempt retail facilities to additional safety standards in order to address a 'particular significant risk.' Given those specific circumstances, the measure, under our decisions, qualifies as a standard within the meaning of the OSH Act," the judges ruled in a decision that vacates OSHA's action.

"Because the Memorandum amounts to a standard within the meaning of the OSH Act, we have jurisdiction to review it and to vacate it for failure to comply with the procedural requirements established by that Act. Of course, nothing in our decision necessarily calls into question the substance of OSHA’s decision to narrow the exemption for retail facilities and correspondingly to expand the scope of the PSM Standard. We hold only that, insofar as OSHA does so, it must follow the notice-and-comment procedures for standards set forth in the OSH Act," they held.

Product Showcase

  • AirChek Connect Sampling Pump

    Stay connected to your sampling with the SKC AirChek® Connect Sampling Pump! With its Bluetooth connection to PC and mobile devices, you can monitor AirChek Connect pump operation without disrupting workflow. SKC designed AirChek Connect specifically for all OEHS professionals to ensure accurate, reliable flows from 5 to 5000 ml/min and extreme ease of use. AirChek Connect offers easy touch screen operation and flexibility. It is quality built to serve you and the workers you protect. Ask about special pricing and a demo at AIHA Connect Booth 1003. Read More

  • SwabTek® Cannabis Test Kit

    The SwabTek® Cannabis Test Kit is a single-use spot test designed for use in screening for cannabis compounds in any sample type or on any surface. The test is capable of identifying the presumed presence of cannabinoids in very small quantities, with a level of detection as little as 6 μg in mass. Learn more about the SwabTek® Cannabis Test Kit and the rest of SwabTek surface drug testing solutions through the webinar titled "Everything You Want To Know About Surface Testing" Read More

  • EMSL Analytical, Inc. - Air Sampling Supplies & Testing Labs

    EMSL Analytical, Inc. operates laboratories throughout the United States and Canada. EMSL is a nationally recognized and locally focused provider specializing in fast laboratory results for Asbestos, Mold, Silica, Lead & Metals, Bacteria, Legionella, USP , Combustion By-Products, VOC’s, Radon, PCB’s, Formaldehyde, METH/Fentanyl, Identification of Dust & Unknowns. Sampling Pumps, Cassettes, Media & Supplies available. Reach us at 1-800.220.3675 Read More

Featured

Artificial Intelligence

Webinars