Does OSHA's Jurisdiction Extend to the Baseball Diamond?

In a Sept. 12, 2008, Letter of Interpretation posted to OSHA's Web site Dec. 4, the agency addressed the increased prevalence of baseball bats breaking during professional games, sending shattered pieces flying about the field and into the stands, creating a hazard to players and spectators. Richard E. Fairfax, director of OSHA's Enforcement Programs Directorate, responded to the following two paraphrased questions:

  • Does OSHA have jurisdiction to regulate the safety of professional baseball players as well as spectators at major league games?
  • If OSHA has jurisdiction, in light of a recent surge in shattering bats that send wood fragments out in an explosive manner, can the agency press professional baseball to change back to sturdier wooden bats or to metal bats?

Fairfax said OSHA's authority to protect players, umpires, and others at work on the diamond depends on whether the individuals meet the definition of "employees" or "independent contractors" under the OSH Act. "OSHA has no specific [applicable] standards that address protection for professional athletes playing in games . . . [nor] standards for protecting professional baseball players at bat or for protecting other employees in proximity to batters at major league games," he wrote, noting that the agency's jurisdiction is dependent on an employer-employee relationship. "Without that relationship, our standards are not applicable."

Fairfax pointed to a June 23, 2003, LOI that addressed whether professional athletes were contractors or employees. "In that letter, we stated that '[t]his determination must be made on a case-by-case basis after considering all of the circumstances affecting the relationship between the teams and their players and applying the common law factors.' In most cases, however, OSHA does not take enforcement action with regard to professional athletes."

As for the safety of spectators at professional sports events, Fairfax noted that the agency's standards apply only to the employer-employee relationship and not to employer activities that can affect the general public. Thus, the hazard of shattered bat shards striking spectators "does not fall under the Agency's jurisdiction and, as such, does not provide a rationale for Agency action," he wrote.

Industrial Hygiene Product Showcase

  • Ventis® Pro5

    Ventis® Pro5

    The Ventis Pro5 is the most flexible connected gas monitor on the market, giving you the power to protect workers from up to five gases, manage worker safety from remote locations, and simplify team communication to take the guesswork out of gas detection. It automatically shares real-time gas readings, man-down, and panic alarms between peers – meaning the entire team knows who is in danger and why. By sharing real-time data, workers can also maintain continuous communication without the need for additional infrastructure or devices. Visit us at AIHce booth #927 to learn more! 3

  • Combustible Dust Testing & Process Consulting

    Combustible Dust Testing & Process Consulting

    Industrial Hygiene hazards should include potential combustibility hazards. Our labs provide testing for combustible dust, vapor and chemical reaction hazards. Fauske & Associates uses testing data to solve process safety issues and mitigate potential accidents in the chemical and nuclear industries. Custom solutions include site assessments, testing, engineering, consulting and training. 3

  • Tether Track™

    Tether Track™

    Tether Track™ Protects Your People From Fall Risks Gorbel’s Tether Track™ Rigid Rail Fall Arrest Anchor Systems are a cost-effective way to reduce the risk of worker injury in elevated work environments. They’re available in Ceiling Mounted, Free Standing Monorail, and Bridge Anchor Systems. Customized solutions designed to fit your needs in either indoor or outdoor settings. Reduce the risk of falls without impacting productivity! 3

Featured

Webinars