High Court Clarifies Employers' Burden in Age Discrimination Claims

The U.S. Supreme Court issued major age discrimination decisions today. The court handed a defeat to the EEOC and a Kentucky retiree from a sheriff's department who challenged the state's failure to increase his pension when he became disabled after retiring, but it sided in a second decision with a worker who challenged his dismissal from KAPL Inc., which operates the federal government's Knolls Atomic Power Laboratory. The crux of this ruling, in Meacham, et al. v. Knolls Atomic Power Laboratory, is that employers, not employees, bear the burden of demonstrating a layoff was based on reasonable factors other than age.

The Meacham decision was 7-1, while the Kentucky case -- Kentucky Retirement Systems, et al. v. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, was a 5-4 decision. Justice David Souter, writing for the Meacham majority, said employer groups should not fear the decision will spur a flood of age discrimination cases for which employers must produce lots of evidence, incurring a heavy expense. "It will be mainly in cases where the reasonableness of the non-age factor is obscure for some reason, that the employer will have more evidence to reveal and more convincing to do going from [evidence] production to persuasion [of the judge]," Souter wrote.

The plaintiff in the Meacham case, Clifford B. Meacham, was one of 31 workers laid off by KAPL for fiscal year 1996 after managers scored employees for "performance," "flexibility," and "critical skills." Thirty of the 31 were at least 40 years old, and 28 of them sued, only to lose when the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals held that the employees had the burden to show the non-age factor was unreasonable.

Download Center

  • EHS Buyer's Guide

    Download this buyer's guide to make more informed decisions as you're looking for an EHS management software system for your organization.

  • Online Safety Training Buyer's Guide

    Use this handy buyer's guide to learn the basics of selecting online safety training and how to use it at your workplace.

  • COVID Return-to-Work Checklist, Fall 2021

    Use this checklist as an aid to help your organization return to work during the COVID-19 pandemic in a safe and healthy manner.

  • SDS Buyer's Guide

    Learn to make informed decisions while searching for SDS Management Software.

  • Risk Matrix Guide

    Risk matrices come in many different shapes and sizes. Understanding the components of a risk matrix will allow you and your organization to manage risk effectively.

  • Industry Safe

Featured Whitepapers

OH&S Digital Edition

  • OHS Magazine Digital Edition - September 2021

    September 2021

    Featuring:

    • COMBUSTIBLE DUST
      Managing Combustible Dust and Risk Mitigation
    • PPE: CONSTRUCTION
      The Rising Popularity of Safety Helmets on the Jobsite
    • PPE: ELECTRICAL SAFETY
      Five Tips for a Successful Wear Trial
    • SAFETY & HEALTH
      Medical Surveillance Versus Medical Screening
    View This Issue