Next Level Safety Cultures

Senior managers have become increasingly aware of Safety’s potential returns, well beyond loss reduction. And Safety culture is an especially hot topic among leaders who sense something is missing— that performance could be better.

Their instincts are probably right.

Culture is like the air we breathe: invisible, but very real. It’s what people really believe but don’t necessarily talk about— what you can get away with vs. what sparks the attention of Executives. What you have to do to get promoted, and much more.

There are likely thousands of cultures. In fact, many pocket cultures can exist within one company. And a plant’s graveyard shift typically has very different “air” than its day shift.

So why bother focusing on Safety culture? If you, like me, are dedicated to significant, ongoing improvements, it’s important to first map where you want to go. Identifying your level of Safety culture can also help communicate urgency for change up and down your organization.

Practically, I’ve found there are four overall stages of Safety culture. Many companies “graduate” up these cultural levels; others become mired at one level. If this is your case, consider how this 4-stage overview might provide perspective for becoming unstuck.

1. Forced Safety Culture. Here, Safety is “Done To” others—by command and control. These companies inherently view Safety as a blockage to business. So they do the least necessary to stay in compliance with regulating agencies. Managers similarly expect compliance from workers.

Safety people are typically understaffed and can think of themselves as Safety Police: enforcement first, surprise inspections to unearth violations. Punishment soon follows, so workers cover their rears in accident investigations and audits.

2. Protective Culture, where Safety is “Done For” workers. Performance is average. This type of company begins seeing Safety as important. They often proclaim, “Safety is #1!” (They then lose credibility when production or other pressures take front seat.)

They seek to make the workplace safe by controlling, top-down, benevolent parent-like, and to bypass the need for strict compliance. Common thought process: “If everyone did as they were directed, all would be well.” This culture is big on policies and procedures. And if one policy doesn’t get results, “experts” write even more explicit directives.

Emphasis is on engineering fixes, dealing with injuries after they’ve occurred, and incentives. This culture still seeks quick and cheap solutions to complex and longstanding problems (back belts, safety bingo, etc.).

Managers are often perplexed at lackluster performance, then blame workers for “not doing what’s good for them.”

3. Involved Cultures are “Done With” employees—and well done. Performance is above average. Managers see Safety as an opportunity to involve workers and boost morale. Emphasis goes beyond injury prevention to “soft benefits”—retention, building trust, receptivity to change, engagement, more. This culture trains supervisors and discusses off-work Safety. Training becomes geared to judgment, problem-solving, and skills. Involved companies approach behavioral auditing as a more positive process than do Forced cultures.

As one EHS Director said, these companies have done a good job of “picking off the low-hanging fruit.” But there’s still potential produce left unharvested on the tree.

After significant improvements, attentional/ behavioral/statistical performance regrettably plateaus when the culture dwells on self-congratulations (such as shoulder injuries from patting themselves on the back). Managers worry about workers becoming “complacent” but often don’t see they’ve modeled overself- satisfaction.

4. Integral Cultures are those where Safety is “Done By” workers, for themselves. Performance is global class—and continuously watched.

People see Safety as energizing, interesting and practical.

Self-regulation is the norm; people engage in safe actions even when they know no one’s watching. This culture focuses on self-monitoring more than external auditing. Motivation moves toward recognition, beyond external incentives. Executives often actively sponsor new initiatives. Safety committees are active and have decision power, training, and often a budget. Some employees become trained as catalysts of Safety improvement (trainers, coaches, and reinforcement agents). There’s a strong focus on off-work Safety training, with PPE to take home.

This culture has significant internal drive to remain cutting-edge, pioneering new and effective initiatives and not resting on their laurels.

Safety Culture Reflects Overall Culture
These descriptions are only the tip of an iceberg. There’s much more to each culture than I can cover here: motivational systems, leadership styles, approach to prevention, and post-injury reactions.

Safety cultures strongly reflect overall culture. I’ve never seen a strong organizational culture that had a weak Safety culture, and vice versa. So by leading stronger Safety culture, you can in turn move your company to higher ground in performance, profitability and morale.

This article originally appeared in the May 2008 issue of Occupational Health & Safety.

Product Showcase

  • Matrix's OmniPro Vision AI Collision Avoidance System

    OmniPro Vision AI is a state-of-the-art collision avoidance system that features NIOSH award-winning Visual Artificial Intelligence (AI) technology. This highly accurate, powerful system identifies and alerts on pedestrians, vehicles and specified objects, ensuring safer facilities, mining operations and industrial sites. With its web-based cloud application, OmniPro Vision AI also logs and analyzes a wide range of data related to zone breach notifications. Operating without needing personal wearable devices or tags, OmniPro has visual and audible zone breach alerts for both operators and pedestrians. Read More

  • Safety Knives

    The Safety Knife Company has developed a quality range of safety knives for all industries. Designed so that fingers cannot get to the blades, these knives will safely cut through cardboard, tape, strapping, shrink or plastic wrap or a variety of other packing materials. Because these knives have no exposed blades and only cut cardboard deep, they will not only protect employees against lacerations but they will also save product. The Metal Detectable versions have revolutionary metal detectable polypropylene knife bodies specifically for the food and pharmaceutical industries. This material can be detected and rejected by typical detection machines and is X-ray visible. Read More


    With alkaline or rechargeable options, these safety rated, Class 1, Div. 1 Headlamps provide long runtime with both spot and flood options in the same light. Work safely and avoid trip hazards with flexible hands-free lighting from Streamlight. Read More